Why Do We Need New Models?
The Problem for Scholars
"Over the course of the last few decades, most Departments of language
and literature have come to demand that junior faculty members
produce, as a condition for being seriously considered for promotion
to tenure, a full-length scholarly book published by a reputable
press. A small number of departments expect the publication of two
such books. Whether these expectations are reasonable or necessary is
a question that we should collectively ponder and debate. The
immediate problem, however, is that university presses, which in the
past brought out the vast majority of scholarly books, are cutting
back on the publication of works in some areas of language and
literature. Indeed, we are told that certain presses [Stanford...]
have eliminated editorial positions in our disciplines. Many factors
are involved here, but the core of the problem -- which extends
beyond our fields to such disciplines as philosophy, musicology,
and anthropology -- is systemic, structural, and at base economic."
--Stephen Greenblatt, A Letter to MLA Members (republished in the Chronicle of Higher Education, Tuesday, July 2, 2002) |